Thursday, July 5th, 2012 at 9:46 am
Murphy’s law and others give not exactly hard and fast guidelines for prediction of events and interpretations. My (just coined as such) first Rule is the following
Conventional Historical Wisdom is always wrong.
In what follows this will be applied to the third rail of historical discourse … vis a vis to suggest that the Jewish narrative concerning the Holocaust is wrong. This may or may not be a historical third high voltage line as suggested above, but there are blogging/pirate rules that state any you mentions Nazis loses the argument … and Nazis will be noted in this piece.
For a long time references to the Holocaust have bothered me, in that the focus on that particular feature of German/Nazi atrocities has overwhelmed our historical recall of other Nazi (and concomitant Soviet ones). When one recalls mass murders in the mid 20th century …. with rare exceptions only one thing will be recalled and the others minimized or forgotten. This is wrong. Do not misunderstand, the fault for this lies with historians, teachers and educators … not with the Jewish people. Their memory, their remembrance is apt and warranted. What is not is for the rest of us to forget that this was just a small part of a larger horrific picture.
If, in a recent non-mass killing like that at Columbine, if 10 persons had been killed of which 4 Muslims had been killed if conventional wisdom called this an attack on Islam that would be wrong. It would not be wrong for Islamic faith communities to remember this in their own way. It would however be wrong for everyone to do that. Similarly remembering the mass murders of the 20th century in Eastern Europe as being only about the Holocaust would also be wrong. This is however, the conventional story.
Read the rest of this entry
Thursday, July 5th, 2012 at 9:01 am
Good morning. We’ll try a comma, pause, comma edition.
- My youngest daughter starts driving this fall, so, is this good advice or not?
- A problem of our time for, well, many.
- So would that poster/graphic work, perhaps, as the main thread of a graduation speech?
- Diaspora, and then, return.
- Here’s an interesting question, does your the meta-X work consistently with the micro-X and macro-X as exemplified here with ethics and political theory (and I couldn’t figure out how to transform that into comma, pause, comma … sorry). Note, that’s not specific tenents of micro/macro but the meta layer.
- While Congress wastes its time on college loan matters, surprise, they ignore arguably more important flaws within the secondary educational system.
- Remember how the liberal of so many stripes bemoaned certain language in political discourse after a certain shooting, well, will this be remarked?
- Tears don’t work, really its true, in Legislative bodies in a close vote.
- Slurp and Zaap!
- This didn’t turn out how I’d expect, really, not at all.
- Considering wages and minimums, and well, justice.
- The reality of the so called reality based party is, alas, based on lies.
- Mr Romney has shown himself to be very weak regarding his notions of foreign policy, however, so has his opponent.
Wednesday, July 4th, 2012 at 11:10 am
Good day (if just a tad hot).
- On rights and the 4th. Those who thing rights important or useful need to deal with Rousseau’s (if I remember correctly) criticism that rights are insufficient against government which can redefine/define them as they see fit for their purposes … and we see that in action today.
- A reading/viewing list … interesting intersection, I’m trying to read Moby Dick in parallel with China Meiville’s Railsea, ?as the latter seemed from the outset to draw a lot from the former and my memory of Mr Ahab and company is dim.
- Slipped through the liberal eugenics screening programme.
- Making it a law … as if everything were free and adding ~$2k to the cost of a table saw is inconsequential.
- A liberal/progressive maxim … “the US is no longer the greatest country in the world” which oddly enough never proposes an alternative. The reason is that the statement is false. Others may be catching up, but in the words of UK educational maxims (as expressed in this wonderful book) if the US is not “top nation” who is? China with $4/day labor? India? France? Germany? Sweden? Cuba? Get real. If you want to name the US as not “top nation” you need to indicate which nation replaced the US.
- Of taxation and consent.
- Which founder?
- Oooh, I did this (sort of) for my kids. When they were little and worried about the noise from the freight trains going through town … I told them, don’t worry, if it gets off the rails, the “snake” will get it.
- To what purpose.
- A Saint and romance.
- Unnoticed and forgotten peoples.
- There will always be war?
- On union labor and freedom.
Wednesday, June 27th, 2012 at 11:22 am
Woo hoo. I’m still here. Actually, weekend travel + Monday I was on site all day sans Internet, and then I’ve come down with laryngitis and between trying to work and sleep blogging has taken the hit.
- Circumcision and Germany, two views here and here.
- Magic … the interesting inclusion of “contagion” prompted me to link this … sounds kind like quantum entanglement, eh?
- Unimpressed by a TV mini-series.
- And a film review.
- A thank you from Mr Barnett … I’d link a thank you from the other side of the aisle but didn’t find one. Is that to be expected? Why?
- Big gun.
- Speaking of guns (and bikes!?).
- Economists you like.
- The EU and unexpected exit advice.
- Hunting for the honest liberal with respect to “judicial activism”?
- Having a bad day … nature edition.
- Freedom and university.
- Chicago and stupidity around gun laws.
- Modify the past to effect predictions is not warranted, …. right?
- First birther. Heh.
- Statistics of violent encounters.
Monday, June 18th, 2012 at 7:43 pm
Apparently common construction practice is to build the sewage out piping from your house to extend 3-4 feet with heavy cast iron piping and to use two to three foot lengths of clay pipe after that. A consequence of this is local bushes and trees have roots seeking water sources find the joints in those clay pipes, insinuate themselves and eventually block the pipe. Which in turns either backs up in a basement drain or in a basement toilet, whichever is lower. Ours chose the drain … and a wonderful outflow of stuff was discovered late last night in our laundry room.
Synchronicity abounds however in that we were this weekend (and still have not finished) watching In Darkness, a WWII film concerning a group of less than a dozen Jewish men, women, and children hiding in the sewers in the then Polish Lwow, now Ukrainian city of Lviv. These people owed their life to an anti-semitic sewer worker and the complex nature of Polish/Ukrainian <=> Jewish Polish/Ukraine is explored in the movie. The book on which this is based Girl in the Green Sweater, by my understanding was authored by one of the young girls who survived that which the movie portrays. The synchronicity of course points to the sewage flowing in our basement and in the film … on the same day.